Creamsicle Pie, mini pies with the flavors of the classic creamsicle, perfect for parties or an anytime treat!
Creamsicle Pie is one of my favorite desserts and it will be one of your favorites too!
PIN IT NOW AND SAVE FOR LATER
Creamsicle Pie
These little cuties are so amazingly delicious. When I was growing up, I used to LOVE (and still do!) creamsicles.
I don’t know what it is about them but the ice cream is just soo soo good!
Take me to the recipe for Creamsicle Pie already!
Thank you so much for your eagerness to view my recipe.
If you would rather not hear my super helpful tips and tricks, FAQ, and my overall awesomeness and get straight to this delicious Creamsicle Pie – you can very easily scroll all the way to the bottom of this post for the full printable FREE recipe! Bon appetit.
Sorry, I’m just a little excited for today’s recipe, cantcha tell?! LOL. If you didn’t know, I’m currently living in Florida and we are known for our Florida Oranges!
Starting off with a healthy option like fresh orange juice boosts your nutrition for the day! But, orange juice isn’t just good for breakfast, as you can see in today’s post!
Oranges and orange juice are a major staple around these parts so I’m doing my state proud and featuring our state fruit!
This recipe is based off my MOST POPULAR RECIPE EVER: Individual Frozen Key Lime Pies, you guys sure love those! You’re pretty smart like that, 😉
Orange Cremisicle Pies- the perfect treat!
How to make Creamsicle Pies:
Mix together the cookie crumbs and butter- set aside
Make the creamsicle filling
Dye part of the filling orange then carefully swirl the dyed portion with the undyed portion
Divide the the mixture into 24 silicone cups
Top each cup with cookie crumbs
Freeze until set
Enjoy!
How do I get the pies out of the cupcake liners?
The easiest way I have found to get them out of the cups is to place them crumb side down on a plate and then roll up on the cups.
Don’t try to just push them out from the top or the filling will get all smashed.
Aren’t these cremiscle pies just the cutest?! Not to mention deeee-licious!
The filling is very similar to an ice cream filling- YUM!
Yea, I went a little nuts with the pictures again but these creamsicle pies are just so photogenic! I really hope you liked today’s recipe!!
If you like this recipe make sure to check out my no bake oreo pie, creamsicle yogurt bites, and my blueberry lemonade cocktail!
![]()
Silicone Cupcake Liners
Individual Frozen Creamsicle Pies
Ingredients
- 20 vanilla sandwich cookies made into crumbs
- 4 Tbls unsalted butter melted
- 8 oz cream cheese room temp
- 8 oz whipped topping
- 14 oz sweetened condensed milk
- 3/4 Cup orange juice fresh squeezed
- 1 tsp vanilla bean paste or extract
- food coloring optional
Instructions
- Mix the cookie crumbs with the melted butter, set aside.
- In a large bowl, using a hand mixer cream the cream cheese for 1 minute. Add in the condensed milk and mix to combine. Add in the orange juice and vanilla, very carefully on low speed mix until everything is fully combined. Fold in the whipped topping. Optional: Take about 1/4 of the mixture and place in a separate bowl. Dye a medium orange color.
- Pour the orange mixture back into the original mix. Very carefully just swirl the orange into the mix, not combining it all the way. This way you will get that pretty gradual orange coloring to the pies, like a marble effect.
- Evenly divide the mixture among 24 silicone baking cups. Top off with the cookie crumbs mixture just up to the top of the cups. There should be just enough mix and cookies for 24 cups.
- Place in the freezer until set, this can take up to overnight so prepare ahead of it. Serve with more whipped topping if desired, enjoy!
Nutrition
- Cookies and Cream Red Velvet Brownies - January 20, 2021
- White Chicken Chili (Low Calorie Recipe!) - January 18, 2021
- Stuffed Pepper Soup - January 15, 2021
Melissa
When I first saw these, I thought, “Wow, these remind me of those little key lime pies!” Ha ha! I didn’t know those were yours, too! These sound (and look!) amazing! I am so tempted to go buy some Vanilla Wafers so I can make some today!
Carole
Creamsicles are one of my favs, too! And, don’t worry about too many pictures – your photos are beautiful and extremely pin-worthy!
So, guess what? I’m pinning…
[email protected]
These little frozen treats look incredible and so yummy. Thank you for sharing. PINNED!
chanelle
Wow! These look really good. I have been wanting to make Orange Julius’ at home but perhaps I’ll try these cute little treats instead!
-Chanelle // http://www.thekimchronicles.com
Elizabeth
Oh Dana, you do know your way around a plate! Thank you for sharing. these look divine!
Kristina and Millie
So yummy-licious! these little frozen creamsicle pies are like a touch of summer you can eat year round! nom 🙂 Thanks for sharing the recipe with Snickerdoodle Sunday!
Lindsay Eidahl
My kids would love these. I will have to try them. Thank you for sharing on Show Me Saturday!
[email protected]
O my WOW! This is the best desert I have seen in a while I know every one in my house would love. Wake Up Wed Party on!
Sinea
Oh this recipe is going on my “to do” list! Yummy and pretty too. Pinned!
Cheri at Fabric and Memories
visiting from girlish whims linky… sounds good and a good thing to make the day before…but I dont’ like orange! But I am going to try it with another flavor! Thanks!
Cheri
keri @ shaken together
Dana – these look absolutely delicious! I love not having to share 😉 I picked you as my ROCK STAR for the Creativity Unleashed link party and you’ll be featured tonight! Shout out the party and rally the troops to vote for your recipe 🙂
Cheryl
Made and enjoyed, but they didn’t come out of silicone cups as pretty as yours. Did you let them sit out of the freezer at all before removing?
Dana DeVolk
If they are super frozen, I will run them under warm water first. But, if they do set out for a couple of minutes, that should do the trick. I also kind of flip the silicone inside out as I peel it off the pies, if that makes sense.
Heather
Yummy!! 🙂
Just one question: once they are frozen and set, do they have to stay in the freezer, or could they hang out in a refrigerated case for a day or two?
Dana DeVolk
They need to stay in the freezer to stay solid 🙂