This post may contain affiliate links.
Classic potato salad is the side dish that lives on every backyard table from Memorial Day through Labor Day, the creamy mayo, hard-boiled egg, and dill pickle combo Maddie scoops a triple serving of every time we run it next to slow cooker St. Louis ribs on a *hot Sunday afternoon*.
Boil, chop, mix, chill, that is the entire game and dinner is on the table.
Classic Potato Salad Quick Look
- 🕐 Prep Time: 15 minutes
- 🍴 Cook Time: 20 minutes
- ⏳ Total Time: 1 hour 35 minutes
- 🍽 Serving: 6 servings
- ⚡ Calories: 420kcal
- 🌶 Flavor Profile: Creamy, tangy, savory, with hints of sweet pickle
- ✋ Difficulty: Easy, on par with our creamy garlic dressing
Quick Answer
Boil peeled russet potatoes 20 minutes until fork tender, drain and toss with vinegar to cool, hard boil 5 eggs, dice the cooled potatoes and 4 eggs, add diced red onion and dill pickle, whisk a mayo and yellow mustard dressing with sugar and pinch of salt, fold everything together, garnish with the remaining sliced egg and chives, and chill for at least 30 minutes before serving.
Jump to:
Why This Recipe Works
Click to see the technique science
- Russet potatoes soak up dressing. The starchy flesh of russets holds the mayo and mustard better than waxy potatoes, giving you that classic dressed bite all the way through.
- Warm potato vinegar splash. Tossing the still warm potatoes with a tablespoon of vinegar lets them absorb the acidity, which seasons from the inside and balances the rich mayo later.
- Hard boiled eggs do double duty. Diced into the mix for richness, sliced on top for the visual cue everyone expects on a classic potato salad.
- Dill pickle plus red onion balance the mayo. Crunch and sharp bite cut through the creamy dressing so each bite reads layered instead of one note creamy.
- Chill time melds the flavors. Even 30 minutes in the fridge lets the dressing settle into the potatoes and the mayo flavors deepen. Overnight is even better.
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
- Cookout side dish hero. Pairs with every grilled meat on the menu and feeds a crowd from one big bowl.
- Make ahead winner. Build the day before, chill overnight, serve cold from the fridge. The flavors get better as it sits, same trick we use for our crock pot pulled pork sandwiches sides.
- Pantry plus a few fresh. Six pantry ingredients plus potatoes, eggs, red onion, and pickle, the kind of recipe you can pull off after a quick grocery run.
Key Ingredients
- Russet potatoes: Three pounds of peeled russets. Starchy flesh holds the creamy mayo dressing better than waxy potatoes, the bedrock of classic potato salad.
- Eggs: Five large eggs, four diced into the salad for richness, one sliced for the iconic top garnish.
- Mayonnaise: One and a half cups of full fat mayo for the creamy backbone. Skip the low fat or olive oil versions, they water down the dressing.
- Yellow mustard: A tablespoon for tang and color, the same all-American mustard that lifts our hot dog sauce.
- Dill pickle plus red onion: A third cup diced dill pickle and half cup diced red onion for the crunch and sharp pickled note that defines classic potato salad versus a plain potato mash.
See recipe card for exact quantities.
Variations and Substitutions
- Add crumbled bacon. Six slices of crispy bacon crumbled in turn classic potato salad into a loaded version with extra savory hit.
- Try Yukon gold potatoes. Yukon golds give a buttery texture if you want a slightly waxier bite than russet.
- Swap the pickle. Sweet pickle relish instead of dill pickle for a sweeter Southern style, or use bread and butter pickles for a middle ground.
- Add fresh dill. A tablespoon of chopped fresh dill brightens the dressing and adds that deli case potato salad note.
- Make it Southern style. Mix in a splash of pickle juice plus a teaspoon of celery seed for a Memorial Day style classic potato salad closer to our Southern collard greens tradition.
How to Make Classic Potato Salad
- Boil the potatoes. Peel the russets and cut them in half so they cook evenly. Place them in a medium saucepan, cover with cold salted water, bring to a boil, then reduce to medium low and simmer covered for 20 minutes until fork tender. Drain immediately in a colander and run cold water over them for 30 seconds to stop the cooking.
- Vinegar splash for seasoning. Return the still warm potatoes to the empty pot and sprinkle 1 tablespoon of vinegar over them. Toss lightly and let them sit uncovered for 5 minutes so the vinegar absorbs into the flesh, seasoning from the inside.
- Hard boil the eggs. Place 5 eggs in a saucepan and cover completely with cold water. Bring to a full boil with the lid on, turn off the heat, and let sit covered for exactly 10 minutes. Drain the hot water, run cold water over the eggs until cool to the touch, then peel and chill in the fridge until completely cold.
- Dice everything. Once the potatoes are completely cool, dice into 3/4 inch chunks and place in a large mixing bowl. Dice 4 of the cold hard-boiled eggs and add them to the bowl with the potatoes. Save the fifth egg for slicing on top as the garnish.
- Add the crunch. Stir in the finely diced red onion and dill pickle, mixing gently with a rubber spatula so the potatoes do not break apart. The crunch and pickled bite are what set classic potato salad apart from a basic mash.
- Whisk the dressing. In a small bowl, whisk together the mayonnaise, yellow mustard, sugar, salt, pepper, and 1 teaspoon of finely chopped chives until smooth and pourable. Taste the dressing on a potato chunk and adjust salt before adding the full batch.
- Fold and chill. Pour the dressing over the salad and fold gently to coat every chunk evenly without crushing the potatoes. Top with the sliced egg and remaining chives, cover with plastic wrap, and chill at least 30 minutes before serving for the flavors to meld.
Recipe Tips & Tricks
- Cool the potatoes fully. Warm potatoes melt the mayo into a greasy puddle. Spread the cubed potatoes on a sheet pan for 15 minutes to speed the cool.
- Salt the boil water. A generous tablespoon of salt in the boil water seasons the potatoes from the inside, the same trick that makes our Southern collard greens taste right.
- Use a serrated egg slicer. Clean even slices on top look better and slice through the white without crushing the yolk.
- Add the dressing in two batches. Half first, fold, taste, then add the rest. You may not need every drop depending on potato moisture.
- Chill before serving. Even 30 minutes makes a big difference. Overnight in the fridge is the gold standard.
- Garnish just before serving. Sliced egg and fresh chives go on top right before you carry the bowl to the table, they wilt fast in the fridge.
- Taste and adjust. Different mayo brands have different salt levels. Always taste the finished salad before serving and add a pinch more salt if it needs it.
Serving Ideas and Suggestions
Classic potato salad is the BBQ table anchor that pairs with everything off the grill. Plate it next to slow cooker St. Louis ribs with a tall glass of sweet tea, and the cookout is officially open.
For a Sunday dinner spread, serve alongside crock pot pulled pork sandwiches and a stack of dill pickles. Cool creamy potato salad cuts through the sweet smoky pork sauce for the perfect summer plate.
If dessert is on the menu, finish the meal with our no bake key lime eclair cake for a make ahead duo that lets you build everything in advance and just plate when guests arrive.
Classic Potato Salad FAQs
Russet potatoes are best for classic potato salad because the starchy flesh soaks up the dressing. Yukon gold also works for a buttery texture if you want a slightly waxier bite.
Classic potato salad lasts up to 3 days in the fridge stored in an airtight container. After day 3, the dressing breaks down and the eggs go off, so it is best eaten sooner.
Yes, classic potato salad is built for make ahead. Assemble the day before, cover, and refrigerate. The flavors meld overnight and taste better the next day.
Watery classic potato salad usually means the potatoes were not drained well or were still warm when dressed. Cool the potatoes completely and pat dry with paper towels before mixing with mayo.
Mayo based classic potato salad does not freeze well. The dressing separates and the potatoes go grainy on thaw. Make smaller batches and eat within 3 days instead.
Try adding crumbled bacon, fresh dill, celery, or a splash of pickle juice for more flavor in classic potato salad. A pinch of paprika on top adds color and a gentle warm note.
Other Recommended Summer Side Recipes
If this classic potato salad made the BBQ table feel complete, drop a star rating and a comment telling us how everyone scored it. Pictures of your bowl on Pinterest make our day.
For the 3-minute porch sipper that turns brunch into a magazine-worthy moment, our white wine spritzer at the BBQ table uses crisp Pinot Grigio, fresh mixed berries, and a splash of club soda for that classic bubbly summer cocktail.
For a warm crispy counterpart to creamy potato salad, our hot crispy deep fried potato wedges for golden crispy wedges in 18 minutes.
Pair creamy potato salad with our Best Classic Southern Fried Catfish Recipe for golden cornmeal crusted catfish in under 20 minutes.
For an Asian-noodle twist on the family picnic plate, try our Filipino pancit recipe with chicken for savory Filipino bihon noodles in under an hour.
Make this potato salad the perfect side for our oven-baked St Louis Ribs recipe for sticky fall-off-the-bone ribs in under two hours.
Round out your picnic spread with our creamy macaroni salad, the best creamy make ahead side dish loaded with sweet peas, crunchy veggies, and chopped egg in a tangy dressing.
Building a potluck spread? Add our make ahead 5 bean salad for another crowd pleasing side.
A cool, creamy drizzle takes this salad over the top. Whip up a batch of our homemade ranch dressing to spoon over every bite.
Round out your cookout spread with a big bowl of our creamy copycat KFC coleslaw.
Classic Potato Salad
Ingredients
- 3 pounds russet potatoes peeled
- 5 eggs
- 1 Tablespoon vinegar
- 1/2 cup finely diced red onion
- 1/3 cup finely diced dill pickle
- 1 1/2 cups mayonnaise
- 1 tablespoon yellow mustard
- 1 teaspoon sugar
- Salt and pepper to taste
- 2 teaspoons finely cut fresh chives
Instructions
- Peel potatoes. Place potatoes in a medium saucepan and cover with cold water and a lid.
- Bring to a boil; turn down heat to medium low and simmer with the cover on for about 20 minutes – or until a fork inserted into the middle indicates it is tender. Do not over boil, or the potatoes will start to crumble apart and get mushy.
- Immediately drain the potatoes in a colander and run cold water over them.
- Return potatoes to the pot and sprinkle 1 tablespoon vinegar over them. Toss lightly and let them sit in the warm pot for a few minutes. Then return them to the colander to cool completely.
- While the potatoes are cooling, make your hard boiled eggs.
- Place the eggs in a saucepan and cover completely with cold water.
- Cover the pot with a lid and turn heat on to high. Once the water comes to a full boil, turn the heat off the burner, but keep the saucepan (with the lid on) on it.
- Set the timer for 10 minutes. Once the time is up, drain the water off the eggs and run cold water over them.
- Once they have cooled slightly, peel, rinse, and place in a bowl in the fridge to cool completely.
- Once the potatoes have cooled completely, dice them into ¾ inch chunks and place in a large bowl.
- Dice 4 eggs and add them to the bowl with the potatoes. Save the additional egg for slicing for garnish.
- Add the diced red onion and pickle to the potatoes and eggs and mix all together well.
- Make the potato salad dressing by mixing together in a bowl the mayonnaise, mustard, sugar, salt and pepper, and 1 teaspoon fresh chives.
- Pour the dressing over the salad and mix together well.
- Garnish with sliced egg and remaining chives.
- Chill well before serving.
Notes
- You can peel your potatoes before or after cooking, people do both methods, do what you think is best for you.
- How do you prevent potato salad from going watery? Watery potato salad could be caused by a variety of reasons. One way to prevent it is to make sure the potatoes are drained well and cooled completely before the salad is mixed together.
- If you are someone who likes more of a zippy, tangy potato salad flavor, you may want to add up to 1 Tablespoon vinegar to the salad dressing. Add less and taste it first, and then add more if you want it tangier.
- You can use any potato that you like the best ones to use are Russet, Yukon Gold, and Red as they hold up well after cooking.
- You can add many different things to this salad to your liking, like I said this is a base to build off of.
Nutrition
Love This Recipe?
Follow @ThisSillyGirlsKitchen on Instagram and @danadevolk on Pinterest for more!
